By Friday your customers will be buried in offers from companies they have never bought from. The business that fixed their furnace in March will most likely say nothing at all. A thank-you to the people who already paid you is the cheapest message you will send this year, and this is the season it fits.
Most owners spend December chasing strangers. The ads go up, the offers go out, and every new customer has to be found, convinced and paid for. Meanwhile there is a file somewhere, in the invoicing software or the scheduling tool or a spreadsheet, full of people who already know where you are, what you charge and whether you showed up on time.
Thanksgiving is the one week of the year a business can say thank you without it sounding like a tactic. It is also a good excuse to do a job that keeps getting put off: finding out who has bought from you and has not been back.
Why the people you already served are worth more than they look.
In 1990 Frederick Reichheld and W. Earl Sasser published an article in the Harvard Business Review called Zero Defections. They looked at what happens to profit when a service company loses fewer of its customers. Reducing defections by 5 percent produced 30 percent more profit at an auto-service chain, 50 percent more at an insurance brokerage and 85 percent more in one bank’s branch system.
Those were large companies and the numbers are old, but the reason has not changed. A customer who comes back did not have to be found. They need less explaining, they are easier to schedule, and they tell other people. A stranger has to be bought.
In our last entry a made-up shop spent $1,800 on marketing in a month and gained 12 new customers. That is $150 to win each one. Hold on to that figure.
The sum, for a made-up shop.
Take a made-up heating and air company. Its file holds 800 past customers. These are customers, not leads: people who paid for a job. Once the duplicates, the dead addresses and the people who moved come out, it can reach 600. That shrinkage is normal. Most lists turn out to be 10 to 30 percent smaller than the number in the owner’s head.
Say an average job is worth $300, and the company sends those 600 people a thank-you now and one useful reminder in January. If one in a hundred books, that is 6 jobs and $1,800. If three in a hundred book, 18 jobs and $5,400. If five in a hundred book, 30 jobs and $9,000.
One to five in a hundred is the honest range for a quiet list worked properly. We have seen better. We have also seen a list so old that nothing landed, which is worth finding out before you spend on anything bigger.
Now set that beside the $150. To win 18 new customers the usual way, the shop in our last entry would spend $2,700. The thank-you costs an afternoon with the list, an hour of writing, and stamps if you choose to mail.
Two cautions keep the sum honest. It is revenue, not profit, so take your own margin off before you get excited. And some of those people were coming back anyway. Count the ones who booked because you wrote.

Send a thank-you, and nothing else.
No coupon and no countdown. An offer turns a thank-you into an ad, and this week your customers have plenty of ads. The message has three parts: who you are, one true detail about the work you did for them, and a way to answer.
For the made-up heating company it could read: Hi Dana, this is Mark at Ridgeview Heating and Air. We replaced your blower motor in March, and I wanted to say thank you for trusting us with it. If anything is acting up before the cold sets in, reply here and it comes straight to me.
That is the whole message. It comes from a person, it could only have been written to her, and a reply reaches someone who will answer it the same day. If nobody will be there to answer, do not send it yet.
How it travels matters as much as what it says.
- By text. Only to the people who agreed to hear from you by text. Having a number from a past job is not permission to market to it. Put a way to stop in every message.
- By email. Include a working way to unsubscribe and your mailing address. The federal CAN-SPAM rules require both in commercial email, and a thank-you from a business is close enough to treat it that way.
- By card. For your best fifty customers, a handwritten card beats both. Nobody has ever marked one as spam.
In January, one useful message. Then count.
The thank-you opens the door. Two to four weeks later, send the second message, and make it useful. The date of the last job tells you what is due: the tune-up before the hard cold, the filter that should have been changed by now, the six-month visit. If you want to make an offer, this is where it belongs. Keep it plain and give it an end date.
Then count four things, by hand if you have to. Opens are not one of them. As we wrote last week, that counter stopped meaning much in 2021.
- Replies. Every answer, including the ones that only say thanks.
- Bookings. Jobs on the calendar from people on the list.
- Dollars. What those jobs were worth, written beside the names.
- Stops. Everyone who unsubscribed or asked you to stop, taken off the list the same day.
Start this week.
None of this needs new software. It needs the list you already have and about three hours.
- Today. Export everyone who has paid you in the last three years and has not been back in twelve months.
- This week. Take out the duplicates, the bounced addresses and anyone who asked not to hear from you.
- The Tuesday or Wednesday after Thanksgiving. Send the thank-you to ten people first and read it on your own phone, then send the rest. By then the worst of the sale emails is over.
- Every day after. Answer each reply the day it arrives.
- In January. Send the useful reminder, and add up the four counts.
If you would like the sum done with your own two numbers, the reactivation calculator on our site runs it three ways, including the way where it does not clear. Nothing you type there is stored or sent.
And if you would rather hand the whole job over, Customer Reactivation is our sixty-day version: your list cleaned and sorted, the messages written in your voice, the follow-up answered, and every job it brings back counted.
To everyone who hired Etch this year: thank you. We mean it.